Best Thrift Stores In NJ: Affordable Secondhand Clothes Shops

Thrift shopping is an exciting process, but it can get tiring if you don’t know the right stores to visit. Here’s a comprehensive, simple list of the best thrift stores New Jersey has to offer!

Best Thrift Stores In NJ

1. Thrift Shop of Hope

Located on a cozy street in Englewood, New Jersey, Thrift Shop of Hope is a thrift store that provides a variety of items, like clothing, shoes, accessories, furniture, household items, and more.

Thrift Shop of Hope is a large store with many exciting items to sort through. Customers are thrilled with pleasant staff interactions and the overall shopping experience. Thrift Shop of Hope is unique because it supports education and environmental conservation.

All books in this store are free to those in need, and they use part of their profits to support these causes. Another cause the store prioritizes is the fight to end children’s cancer by donating to Saint Jude’s Hospital. Items are quite affordable and there are changing rooms where customers can try on clothing for a fit agreement before they purchase them.

2. The Center Square Thrift Shop

The Center Thrift Shop is an extremely clean, well-run thrift store in Belmar, New Jersey. It is a donation shop that is operated by The Center and volunteers. Unlike some other thrift stores, this shop is a bit smaller, but it has a large selection.

It has a very cozy and comfortable atmosphere with helpful staff. Locals love this thrift shop because of how well-organized the layout of the store is. It is easy to sift through items and find quality merchandise.

Customers also praise this store for being exceptionally clean, which is great given that some thrift stores can feel musty and old.

3. Thriftnicks

Thiftnicks has made a name for itself on TikTok and is a great New Jersey thrift shop located in East Rutherford. Thriftnicks is best known for the variety of random items available to customers. Each visit there is a different assortment of gadgets and gizmos.

There are clothes, jewelry, bags, and other household items in stock. Most customers say it’s like delving through a grandparents’ basement and never knowing what neat antique item might be hidden. This thrift store is a little chaotic but in the best way.

4. Capital Thrift

Run by Capital Health, the Auxiliary Capital Thrift store is a resale-by-donation store. It is completely managed by a team of volunteers. These volunteers also help fundraise for the Auxiliary projects at the Capital Health Hospital.

Capital Thrift is located in Lawrence Township, New Jersey and they are always looking for more volunteers. Locals report that the volunteers that are on hand are friendly, and keep the store extremely clean. This thrift shop always has a variety of items, but the items do tend to stay the same.

Weekly visits are probably not necessary for most shoppers. The store is run exceptionally well and organized, so everything is easy to find. Most of the items displayed are clothes and household goods, like kitchenware. Prices run a little higher than other thrift stores in the area, but it’s still a great place to check out.

5. Simla Us Thrift Store

Opening in 2019, Simla US Thrift Store is fairly new to Howell Township, New Jersey, but it has big goals. This company is a for-profit textile recycling organization. Their goal is to match every clothing item with another owner.

This thrift store is specifically for clothing items and aims to prevent textile waste. Simla US’s tagline is “Nothing goes to waste,” and they are currently partnered with Kids Kicking Cancer and send a portion of their profits annually to the charity. Customers love this store’s amazing prices and their great selection of quality second-hand clothing.