Best Thrift Stores In Indianapolis: 5 Shops For Vintage Thrifting

If you are a fan of race cars, then you probably know a lot about Indianapolis already. Commonly called Indy, it’s the capital of Indiana and the racing capital of the world. It hosts three of the world’s biggest single-day races, which are the Indy 500, the Brickyard 400, and the U.S. Grand Prix Formula One race. It’s not all about racing, though. Indianapolis has a thriving art community and strong local engagement, which is apparent when you visit its host of thrift stores.

Best Thrift Stores in Indianapolis

1. Mission 27 Resale

Mission 27 Resale is named to honor St. Vincent de Paul’s ministry to the poor and September 27th, which is his feast day. This thrift store is run by a volunteer group called the Society of St. Vincent de Paul. Their goal is to raise funds for their food pantries and their Changing Lives Forever program, which is a financial health program for those in poverty. Its merchandise is a lot like Goodwill. You can find pretty much everything here. There are plenty of used and donated clothes, home goods, furniture, appliances, jewelry, toys, and more. Prices are a bit higher than Goodwill’s, though.

2. Making Ends Meet

Making Ends Meet is a local resale store where the real dealers and wheelers go. It has a lot of furniture for people looking to decorate their houses. There is an assortment of merchandise to sort through and the prices are more affordable than in many other places. They have a reasonably good rotating inventory, so you can pop in and check out new items every once in a while. It’s also a great place to go for items like lamps, bags, or picture frames. Items are generally used and of reasonable quality, but this is one of the stores where you have to look through things to find what you really want.

3. The Toggery Resale Boutique

The founder of The Toggery, perhaps as expected, is from Nottingham, England. Lynn Burrows worked really hard to build this small store from 400 square feet to 4,000 square feet. It caters to women and men in the community who are looking to buy and sell their clothing, accessories, and home decor. The Toggery is well known for having a quality inventory with a unique array of options. Items are always in top-notch condition and they have great customer service. However, their selection for larger sizes is generally quite small. Many customers have found designer items at very low prices, so it’s a great place to check out for steals.

4. Humble Impressions

Everything at Humble Impressions is surprisingly affordable. Almost all items are as cheap as 99 cents. Most items are used, but there is a selection of brand-new donated items as well. Their inventory comes from local religious organizations and the community who are generous with their donations. They try to have free food on hand for people in need. There is a good selection of clothes, DVDs, baby clothes, and toys. The store is led by volunteers and its profits go back to help the community.

5. Audrey’s Place Thrift Store

Audrey’s Place Thrift Store is the place to go if you are looking for furniture or home decor. There are some truly great pieces for affordable prices. The customer service is also excellent and extremely helpful. The shop has been in the community for over 42 years. Items can be picked up or delivered. They have architectural salvage that can add a lot of character to a home.