15 Best Thrift Stores in NYC (2024)

Thrifting in New York City can lead you to some of the best deals you’ve ever seen. As mentioned in our best online thrift stores, thrift shopping promotes sustainable living.

It’s also a good way to practice minimalist living as well. Here are some of the top thrift shops you can go to in NYC.

Best Thrift Stores in NYC

1. 10 ft Single By Stella Dallas

10 ft Single By Stella Dallas sells vintage t-shirts, sweaters, shoes, and much more. As of today, out of 72 reviews on Yelp, the company averages a 4 star rating.

One reviewer noted there are a variety of dead stock items from the 70’s. The pricing for the items you’ll see will be mostly around $25-45. Other items you’ll also find include 80’s rock t-shirts, jean jackets, and flannel clothing.

2. Beacon’s closet

Beacon’s closet specializes in selling vintage and modern clothing. They not only sell them, they buy them and trade for them as well.

The company is based out of Brooklyn and is a female founded company. They believe in supporting the cause of sustainability. Shopping from Beacon’s closet is a good a chance to support a locally owned company.

3. Housing Works

Housing Works has multiple location across New York City. They’re open everyday of the week in the afternoon and early evening.

The items sold at the locations vary. At the 2nd avenue & 64th Thrift Shop, they sell secondhand clothing, shoes, decor, kitchen goods, and furniture.

The organization, Housing Works, is a non-profit that works to end homelessness and AIDS. They offer lifesaving services and continual advocacy.

4. Chelsea Flea

Chelsea Flea is a flea market that features vintage and antique vendors. It runs every Saturday and Sunday between 8 am and 4 pm. Beyond the vintage items you might find, you can also enjoy arts and wine.

5. Crossroads Trading Co.

The Crossroads Trading Co. allows customers to sell their clothes at their store. Feel free to sell them in person or even by mail You can also buy recycled and vintage items.

One reviewer referred to this place as their absolute favorite secondhand store to find cute clothing in Manhattan. Crossroads Trading Company has been in the business of selling secondhand items for nearly 30 years.

6. AuH2O

AuH2O describes themselves as a secondhand, vintage, and upcycled shop. The company is located at 84 E. 7th St. located in New York’s East Village.

You can find items by Depop and also some clothes that were made on Etsy. Most of the clothes are priced between $10-30. Some of the clothing are made out of sustainable items such as linen and rayon.

7. Buffalo Exchange

Similar to other vintage shops, you can sell, trade, and buy used clothing. The company as locations not only in NYC, but also in Portland and San Diego In total, they have 43 stores nationwide.

Buffalo Exchange has been arouund is 1974. One reviewer described the clothes as slightly expensive, but noted that the staff was friendly. You can find both men and women’s clothing as this store.

8. Wonders of Walter

An interesting thing about this store is that the clothes are sold out of the owner’s garage. Wonders of Walter sells a lot of things, including old t-shirts and designer items. You can also find rare designer pumps and boots.

9. Cure Thrift Shop

Cure Thrift Shop is a non-profit that sells high-end vintage clothing. They desire to provide their customers with a vibrant shopping experience.

A reviewer stated they had an excellent selection of clothing that people would actually want to wear. Another customer noted that Cure had a lot of furniture as well. Out of 240 reviews, the company averages a four star rating.

10. Hour Children’s Shop

Hour Children’s Shop is located in Astoria. You can find clothing, furniture, and many other types of items. The company is open between 12pm and 5pm Monday through Saturday.

They’ll also accept any bags of clothing you no longer wear. You can also check if they’ll accept other items you no longer use. Additonally, Hour Children’s Shop happily employs formerly incarcerated women to provide them with job experience.

11. Sunnyside Thrift Shop

If you live closer to Queens, New York, take time to check out Sunnyside Thrift Shop. They sell pre-ownded houseware, apparel, tchotchkes, and books.

A customer described the prices as amazing, which sounds like there’s a chance you’ll get a good deal. Another customer noted that there’s something for everyone there.

12. Loveday 31 Vintage

Vintage clothing isn’t the only thing you’ll find at LoveDay31. You’ll also enjoy looking at vintage accessories and new jewelry made by local designers.

The items might be slightly more pricey compared to vintage stores. Nonetheless, they do feature a variety of options that you’ll enjoy.

13. L Train Vintage

L Train Vintage is a family run business that works hard to provide the best thrift items in New York. They have multiple stores in the area you can shop at.

One customer likes this place so much, they almost don’t want anyone else to know about. The prices are considered to be not overpriced in comparison to other secondhand stores.

14. Grand Street Local

Grand Street Local offers a variety of clothing styles and genres that you can buy. You can sell them a variety of clothing styles too.

You can discover clothing from as far back as the 40’s, and as recent as the 90’s. It’s one of the high-rated thrift shops on this list, with an average star rating of 4.5.

15. Le Point Value Thrift

Le Point Value is a small thrift company that sells shoes, accessories, and clothing. The store expresses that they carry all brands and sizes. It’s located in the Brooklyn area.

Final thoughts on Thrifting in New York

New York is considered one of the fashion capitals of the world. You’re bound to find something unique in one of the thrift locations on this list.

Choose two or three places on here that you think might interest you. Take time to visit each one and see if you can find what you’re looking for. Be bold enough to create a look that makes you feel your best.